In Association with Amazon.co.uk

Home

eBook Directory

News

Have Your Book Published

Contact Us

About Us

Competitions

 

The Future of eBooks Discussed:

Microsoft Reader
Vs.
Adobe Acrobat

Adobe Acrobat:

Adobe is currently the dominant force in ebooks. The benefit of using Adobe is that just about everybody has the software already on their computer or pda. Adobe's reader is free to download. the quality of the documents produced by Adobe Acrobat is superb in Version 5. The letters are crisp and easy on the eye.

On the downside Adobe charges a huge amount for the software to create pdf files. There are a few shareware programs that create pdf documents cheaply. However, when I tried one of these free alternatives, it produced unacceptable errors; fine if you're just emailing a friend, but not okay for someone who wants to distribute documents that look professional.

Microsoft Reader

Microsoft Reader, currently in V2, is a relatively new player in the ebook arena. Typical of Microsoft operations, you should expect to see it's use increase substantially over the next few years.

There are some great features. Check-out text-to-speech, which is not available on the current Adobe Reader. However, what makes it likely that Microsft will dominate in the ebook field is that it provides a free tool to convert Word documents into Microsoft Reader Format (lit). Compare this to the very expensive Adobe Acrobat software.

To create more complex Microsft Reader documents, with chapters and special artwork, you may need to buy software. Yet even here Microsoft wins, as the price is much lower than Adobe Acrobat.

File sizes: Adobe became popular becasue of it's ability to produce small files, perfect for the old modem based internet. On my testing Microsoft's Reader produced some good reductions in file size, but in most cases not as good as Adobe Acrobat. However, on a large document running close to 1000 A4 pages, Microsoft format was less than half the size of Adobe. With broadband becoming more widespread, a few k difference isn't as important as it used to be, and so file size differences won't be as important as other considerations.
So which is it to be? Unless Adobe starts to distribute a free conversion tool that creates simple, reliable pdf documents, then Microsoft will win this war with ease.

 


©2002 Amying Partnership. All material is copyright of Amying Partnership, unless otherwise shown. All Rights Reserved. No copying or reproduction of any part in any format allowed without the express written consent of the copyright owners. If you believe any material on this site contravenes a copyright you own, please contact us immediately; where proof of contravention is clear we will remove the offending articles.